Why this ad?
Skip navigation

no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Skip navigation
Goal: 30,000 Progress: 25,494
Sponsored by: Defenders of Wildlife

A “hunters' rights” organization has formally requested a federal permit to hold a multi-year predator-killing derby in Idaho — on national public lands!

If approved this will be the second competitive wolf-killing competition held in Idaho - and no predator will be safe!

If you think it can't get worse, consider this: The proposed event would take place every winter for five years when wolves and other wildlife are most vulnerable out foraging for food in the snow and extreme cold.

Please stand with us, and call on the BLM to immediately deny this outrageous request!

Sign Here

Dear Ms. Townley,

I am adamantly opposed to the request from Idaho for Wildlife to host a multi-year, commercial derby-style hunt for wolves and other predators on more than 3 million acres of Bureau of Land Management (BLM) public lands in Idaho, including 17 areas specially managed to preserve their wilderness character. This event would be damaging to the affected ecosystem, harmful to threatened and sensitive species, incompatible with modern day scientific principles for public lands and wildlife management, and offensive to the concept of fair chase. I strongly urge you to deny this request for a special use permit to a hold a multi-year predator derby on public lands in Idaho. At the very least, this permit request demands a full Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). The proposed action area is vast, covering a matrix of land types inhabited by several sensitive and threatened species and is proposed to recur annually for five years. These attributes require full and thorough evaluation through the preparation of an EIS.

The proposed derby would continue the violent persecution of wolves in Idaho. Repeated, concentrated targeting of wolves led to the species' extirpation in Idaho historically and could contribute to serious declines in the species again. As a BLM-designated sensitive species, the agency must analyze how the proposed derby will affect its responsibility to sustain wolf populations on BLM lands. Federal taxpayers spent millions of dollars returning this important apex predator back on the landscape, and this event would recklessly undermine that investment.

Further, with up to 500 participants "hunting for as many predators as they are able to harvest within 3 days," the derby is also likely to put other sensitive species at risk. Participants could misidentify their targets and kill wolverines, fishers, kit foxes or Canada lynx, a threatened species listed under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The mass removal of skunks, weasels, jackrabbits and other "predatory" animals could also reduce the prey base for a suite of native carnivores at a time of year when food is scarce.

Proponents of the derby are seeking to repeat the same 3-day event on the same public lands for 5 consecutive years. A chronic, repeated short-term use such as this does not meet the definition of "temporary" under the non-impairment standard for managing wilderness-quality lands. Further, there is a reasonable expectation that this proposed derby will "create a demand for uses that would be incompatible with wilderness management" that do not meet the definition of temporary under this standard. The BLM is required to manage these Wilderness Study Areas "to preserve wilderness characteristics so as not to impair [their] suitability...for designation by Congress as wilderness." Intrusive, unrestrained commercial uses such as predator-killing derbies are an anathema to this objective.

Many hunters have argued that the so-called North American Model of Wildlife Conservation should guide decisions with respect to hunting on BLM-managed lands. This predator derby permit request is clearly inconsistent with the fourth tenet of that model, that Wildlife Should Only be Killed for a Legitimate Purpose. This derby is an inappropriate and unethical commercial contest, set apart from sport hunting or hunting for subsistence. The "Winners" of the derby will receive a financial prize for their take, thus commercializing the taking of these predators, the very antithesis of a "legitimate purpose."

Finally, I urge you to deny this request on the grounds that it is a gross misuse of our public lands. Predator derbies are a 19th century practice that played a significant role in driving species to extirpation, creating the need for the ESA and the reintroduction and continued conservation of many predator species in North America. Hunting in winter, when species can be easily tracked in snow and when most animals are working hard to survive, is also offensive to the tradition of fair chase. The BLM should not condone such activities on the public domain.

Thank you for your consideration.

Petition Signatures

Oct 31, 2014 Diane Holland
Oct 31, 2014 Colleen Olivier
Oct 30, 2014 Emily Young
Oct 30, 2014 Shannon Blea
Oct 30, 2014 Gerry Walsh
Oct 30, 2014 hilary Danch Pretty mean and disgusting!
Oct 30, 2014 NICK DUNSTAN
Oct 30, 2014 Leone Gabruck
Oct 30, 2014 drvipul dave
Oct 30, 2014 Doreen Catuara
Oct 30, 2014 (Name not displayed)
Oct 30, 2014 Linda York
Oct 30, 2014 (Name not displayed)
Oct 30, 2014 D'Arave Willmore
Oct 30, 2014 Laurie Grady
Oct 29, 2014 heidi rodriguez
Oct 29, 2014 Theresa Vekich
Oct 29, 2014 (Name not displayed)
Oct 29, 2014 Barbara Dell
Oct 29, 2014 Brett Comley
Oct 29, 2014 Sally Benardo
Oct 29, 2014 Kristi Dickens
Oct 29, 2014 Lynnie Neal
Oct 29, 2014 Barbara Mathes
Oct 29, 2014 Joan Swain Who is allowing such barbaric behavior to occur? Our representative government? I expect the vast majority of US citizens would find this 'derby' to be disgusting. Stop the insanity!
Oct 29, 2014 Peter Bobbermen
Oct 29, 2014 Patricia Radder
Oct 29, 2014 Martha Strother
Oct 29, 2014 (Name not displayed)
Oct 29, 2014 Eileen Bower
Oct 29, 2014 M Lorraine Rhodes
Oct 29, 2014 hanh doan
Oct 29, 2014 Rosemary Webber
Oct 29, 2014 Diana Lawrence
Oct 29, 2014 viviane vanbuggenhout
Oct 29, 2014 Judith Jabour
Oct 29, 2014 Cynthia Hoyle Thou Shalt Not Kill......
Oct 29, 2014 Christiane Santos
Oct 29, 2014 Lesle Bonds
Oct 29, 2014 Monica Odgers
Oct 29, 2014 Alisa Ostwalt
Oct 29, 2014 Gillian Miller
Oct 29, 2014 Danielle Leonetti
Oct 29, 2014 Marianne de Zwart
Oct 29, 2014 linda ventriglia
Oct 29, 2014 Cheri Smith
Oct 28, 2014 Grzegorz Konieczka
Oct 28, 2014 sarah taylor
Oct 28, 2014 Marilyn Dresser

back to top

Why this ad? Why this ad? Purple Paw Insulated Vest
Share this page and help fund food & care: